Asking the Wrong Questions About Homosexuality – CERC
Your quarrel, sir, is with my creator. The claim that “God made me this way” is a common slogan heard from defenders of homosexuality. This high-minded claim seems to place the matter beyond further argument—for what Christian will say that God doesn’t make us who we are? And if he makes some people gay, then we should accept it. In a speech at a gay-advocacy fundraiser Sunday, Democratic presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg defended his homosexuality in a remark aimed at vice president Mike Pence, a proponent of traditional marriage. Insisting that his homosexual behavior and legal marriage to another man do not contradict his beliefs as an Episcopalian Christian, Buttigieg said:. Does God make people gay? A theologian responds
Sexual attraction does not define identity, a priest has said, after comments attributed to Pope Francis have prompted questions about Catholic doctrine and the nature of sexual orientation. Recently, I was asked why God makes homosexuals the way they are. That, after sharing concerns about people—even Christians, mind you—who prayed for deliverance to no effect. Catholic Church and homosexuality
Now, let's consider the OP's question, " Why did God make me gay?". Let's look at the options, and think through them using the theological tools of the rich Catholic intellectual tradition. Sexual attraction does not define identity, a priest has said, after comments attributed to Pope Francis have prompted questions about Catholic doctrine and the nature of sexual orientation. Thomas Petri OP. 
'God Made Me Gay'
The comments have stirred a controversy about Catholic doctrine on homosexuality, with some media outlets reporting them as a "major shift" in Catholic teaching. The Vatican does not customarily comment on private conversations involving the pope, and has not confirmed or clarified the remarks Cruz attributed to Pope Francis. Many faithful believers experience same-sex attraction while deeply desiring to honor God in their lives. Attraction is complex.
Commentary
The relationship between the Catholic Church and homosexuality is complex and often contentious, involving various conflicting views between the Catholic Church and some in the LGBTQ community. According to Catholic doctrine, solely having same-sex attractions itself is not considered inherently sinful; it is the act of engaging in sexual activity with someone of the same sex that is regarded. By Mary Farrow. Sexual attraction does not define identity, a priest has said, after comments attributed to Pope Francis have prompted questions about Catholic doctrine and the nature of sexual orientation.
Did God Make Me This Way?
In a private meeting with a man who carries many crosses, including some imposed by abuse at the hands of a priest, the pope gave a reminder of God’s love, and of the Church’s love. .
Does God Make People Gay? A Priest Responds
But if it wasn’t, “Why would [God] make someone like this?” It was the wrong question—not because it caused the minister to reconsider everything he believed and the historic church taught about homosexuality, but because, as will be explained later, it ensured the wrong answer. . Does God make people gay? Insight from a theologian
There’s a question that many Christians wrestle with in silence: “Why did God make me attracted to the same sex?” It’s a deeply personal and sometimes painful question, one that can stir confusion, fear, or even shame. If you’re asking this, you’re not alone. Many faithful believers experience same-sex attraction while deeply desiring to honor God in their lives. Let’s walk. .